Read what some of our satisfied insurance customers have to say! If you’d like to provide your feedback, please submit your online review.
Diamond L., Mechanicsville, Maryland“I’ve been with Mattingly for over 10 years. They take the time to get know you, are always helpful and pleasant and are extremely easy to reach when you need assistance. I highly recommend them.”
- RLR L., Mechanicsville, Maryland
“I always get great service from Alice, and I appreciate her so much.”
- JCJustin C., Mechanicsville, Maryland
- SGSamuel G., Mechanicsville, Maryland
“Mattingly provides personalized custom policies to fit your needs. Mr Mattingly came to our home and conducted an initial inspection. He noticed that we had recently completed major upgrades and made sure that we had the coverage needed. In addition we switched our auto coverage and saved hundreds of dollars with better benefits. I highly recommend them. Agent Capps is especially helpful.”
- BBea, Mechanicsville, Maryland
- dwayne d., Mechanicsville, Maryland
“The agents at Mattingly have a great sense of customer service. Most recently Sandy Capps. Great job team !!”
- RBRobert B., Mechanicsville, Maryland
“Julie is my go-to person for all things insurance! Over the last several years we have had many questions that were answered promptly and precisely. Julie is very pleasant to work with and has walked us through the process as new homeowners to well-seasoned policy changes. We highly recommend Julie with Erie!”
- JMJeremy M., Mechanicsville, Maryland
“I’ve personally always dealt with McKenna and it is never anything less than five stars. She is always very professional and kind and knowledgeable. Not only does she take care of my insurance needs but is so thorough and explains everything about my policy and coverages. Would highly recommend this business and McKenna to friends and family!”
- JGJ G., Mechanicsville, Maryland
“AMAZING experience, go see Julie she will work everything behind the scenes! Makes the process seamless!”
- Jacqueline H., Mechanicsville, Maryland
“McKenna is very knowledgeable and very responsive. I would recommend this company.”
- Christine, Mechanicsville, Maryland
“I have used Mattingly Insurance, homeowners for over 35 years. They are a wonderful group to work with, each and every representative. Explanations of different policies are provided to the level of detail you request. We moved out of our original area and still requested their services and they provided quality customer services. Of course Southern MD has a hospitality code of all of their own.”
- AKarthur k., Mechanicsville, Maryland
“Simms Mattingly Insurance Agency has always been responsive to my questions and I believe insures I receive the proper amount of insurance and all the risk credits I am eligible for.”
- LPLisa P., Mechanicsville, Maryland
“I highly recommend Simms-Mattingly Insurance. I’ve been with them for over 20yrs. Alice (my insurance agent) is the most helpful agent I have ever dealt with. She is honest and up front with everything. She does a fantastic job finding the right coverage and insurance at a very competitive price. I’m definitely happy and will always be a loyal customer.”
- CLChristina L., Mechanicsville, Maryland
“Amazing customer service!! Everyone is very friendly and works with you every step of the way!! Highly recommend Simms Mattingly Insurance Agency!!”
- Kevin C., Mechanicsville, Maryland
“SMIA is awesome! They always seem to actually care for the people they cover. At the time I bought my current car, I wasn’t sure I could afford the car payment. I was with another insurance agency at the time and thought I’d get quotes from others. SMIA (Erie) was cheaper than the others. So I switched to them, and it eased my mind. The agent that I have been working with, Julie Slater, is an incredibly awesome person. Always quick to respond and very personable. I highly recommend getting a quote from SMIA. You won’t be disappointed.”
